Skip to content
quotesby

But such a straight identification of religion with any and every form of happiness leaves the essential peculiarity of religious happiness out. The more commonplace happinesses which we get are 'reliefs,' occasioned by our momentary escapes from evils either experienced or threatened. But in its most characteristic embodiments, religious happiness is no mere feeling of escape. It cares no longer to escape. It consents to the evil outwardly as a form of sacrifice - inwardly it knows it to be permanently overcome. ... In the Louvre there is a picture, by Guido Reni, of St. Michael with his foot on Satan's neck. The richness of the picture is in large part due to the fiend's figure being there. The richness of its allegorical meaning also is due to his being there - that is, the world is all the richer for having a devil in it, so long as we keep our foot upon his neck.

William James#57

ReligionHappinessSacrificeSymbolism

About this quote

What does it mean?
James distinguishes religious happiness from ordinary relief, describing it as a willing acceptance of evil as a sacrifice that gives meaning, illustrated by the image of St. Michael standing over Satan.
In plain terms
Religious joy is a conscious, meaningful acceptance of suffering, not just relief.
What can you take from it?
True religious happiness involves embracing sacrifice, not just escaping pain.

Where it applies

  • spiritual counseling
  • theological study

Putting it to work

  • using symbolic art for teaching
  • encouraging purposeful sacrifice

Questions to consider

  • How does one cultivate this kind of happiness?
  • Is sacrifice always beneficial?

Another view

The metaphor may not translate to all religious traditions.

More from William James

  1. It makes a tremendous emotional and practical difference to one whether one accepts the universe in the drab discolored way of stoic resignation to necessity, …

    Permalink to quote #56
  2. When all is said and done, we are in the end absolutely dependent on the universe; and into sacrifices and surrenders of some sort, deliberately looked at and …

    Permalink to quote #58
  3. There must be something solemn, serious, and tender about any attitude which we denominate religious. If glad, it must not grin or snicker; if sad, it must not…

    Permalink to quote #55

Related quotes

  1. HUMANAE VITAE tradendae munus gravissimum, ex quo coniuges liberam et consciam Deo Creatori tribuunt operam, magnis semper ipsos affecit gaudiis, quae tamen al…

    Paul VI (Pope)Paul VI (Pope) quote #1
  2. Dieu s'est fait homme; soit. Le diable s'est fait femme!

    Victor HugoVictor Hugo quote #2
  3. He [God] threatened horrible things to us, if we would not be happy.

    Jeremy TaylorJeremy Taylor quote #2