The gods we stand by are the gods we need and can use, the gods whose demands on us are reinforcements of our demands on ourselves and on one another. What I then propose to do is, briefly stated, to test saintliness by common sense, to use human standards to help us decide how far the religious life commends itself as an ideal kind of human activity . ... It is but the elimination of the humanly unfit, and the survival of the humanly fittest, applied to religious beliefs; and if we look at history candidly and without prejudice, we have to admit that no religion has ever in the long run established or proved itself in any other way. Religions have approved themselves; they have ministered to sundry vital needs which they found reigning. When they violated other needs too strongly, or when other faiths came which served the same needs better, the first religions were supplanted.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- James proposes judging religions by whether they meet human needs and reinforce positive demands.
- In plain terms
- Judge religions by if they help humans meet their needs.
- What can you take from it?
- Evaluate beliefs by their practical human value.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do we judge religious value?
- Which needs matter most?
Another view
Needs vary widely, making standard judgments hard.
More from William James
The transition from tenseness, self-responsibility, and worry, to equanimity, receptivity, and peace, is the most wonderful of all those shiftings of inner equ…
Permalink to quote #72 Is dogmatic or scholastic theology less doubted in point of fact for claiming, as it does, to be in point of right undoubtable? And if not, what command over t…
Permalink to quote #74 A paradise of inward tranquility seems to be faith's usual result.
Permalink to quote #71
Related quotes
I very much believe that we share the same human values... If you scan through all the religions - monotheistic and others - they all preach the same... I thin…
Mohamed ElBaradeiMohamed ElBaradei quote #5 Jesus a pleure, Voltaire a souri; c'est de cette larme divine et de ce sourire humain qu'est faite la douceur de la civilisation actuelle.
Victor HugoVictor Hugo quote #11 The virtue of Paganism was strength: the virtue of Christianity is obedience.
David HareDavid Hare quote #14