Skip to content
quotesby

In such a chain, too, or succession of objects, each part is caused by that which preceded it, and causes that which succeeds it. Where then is the difficulty? But the WHOLE, you say, wants a cause. I answer, that the uniting of these parts into a whole, like the uniting of several distinct countries into one kingdom, or several distinct members into one body, is performed merely by an arbitrary act of the mind, and has no influence on the nature of things. Did I shew you the particular causes of each individual in a collection of twenty particles of matter, I should think it very unreasonable, should you afterwards ask me, what was the cause of the whole twenty. This is sufficiently explained in explaining the cause of the parts.

David Hume#68

ReasonLogicMetaphysics

About this quote

What does it mean?
Explaining the causes of individual parts explains the whole without needing a separate cause for the group.
In plain terms
If you know why every part exists, you know why the whole exists.
What can you take from it?
Avoid asking for causes of aggregates when parts are explained.

Where it applies

  • scientific modeling
  • system analysis
  • philosophy

Putting it to work

  • analyze components deeply

Questions to consider

  • Is the whole more than the sum of parts?
  • When do aggregates need separate causes?

Another view

Emergent properties might require more than just part explanations.

More from David Hume

  1. You need only look around you, replied PHILO, to satisfy yourself with regard to this question. A tree bestows order and organisation on that tree which spring…

    Permalink to quote #67
  2. And why should man, added he, pretend to an exemption from the lot of all other animals? The whole earth, believe me, PHILO, is cursed and polluted. A perpetua…

    Permalink to quote #69
  3. In a word, CLEANTHES, a man who follows your hypothesis is able perhaps to assert, or conjecture, that the universe, sometime, arose from something like design…

    Permalink to quote #66

Related quotes

  1. Logic works; metaphysics contemplates.

    Joseph JoubertJoseph Joubert quote #34
  2. Let us consider the reason of the case. For nothing is law that is not reason.

    John PowellJohn Powell quote #1
  3. La raison et l'amour sont ennemis jures.

    Pierre CorneillePierre Corneille quote #1