[Q: isn't there a certain calculus that someone who is sitting in the shoes of a Condoleezza Rice can make, that they're responsible for the best outcome for American citizens, and there's an upside of going into Iraq which is we get one of the greatest material possessions in world's history, and there're downsides which are: we upset the international community, and maybe there's more terrorism. Couldn't you envision a calculus where they say, sure, that's the reason, and it's a good reason, let's do it. What's the flaw in the calculus?] Oh, I think that's exactly their calculus. But then we ought to just be honest and say, 'Look, we're a bunch of Nazis.' So fine, let's just drop all the discussion, we save a lot of trees, we can throw out the newspapers and most of the scholarly literature, and just come out, state it straight, and tell the truth: we'll do whatever we want because we think we're gonna gain by it. And incidentally, it's not American citizens who'll gain. They don't gain by this. It's narrow sectors of domestic power that the administration is serving with quite unusual dedication...
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Chomsky mocks the moral calculus used to justify Iraq invasion as essentially Nazi-like if honesty were applied.
- In plain terms
- If leaders admitted true reasons for war, it would look like pure domination.
- What can you take from it?
- Honesty about power exposes unjust wars.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What justifies war really?
- Why hide true motives?
Another view
Comparing to Nazis may polarize rather than clarify.
More from Noam Chomsky
We certainly shouldn't trust to deal with [Saddam Hussein] anyone who supported him through his worst crimes, that's insane.
Permalink to quote #108 To gain control over this resource, and have probably military bases there, is a tremendous achievement for world control. You read counter-arguments to this, …
Permalink to quote #110 Let us turn now to the most elementary principle of just war theory, universality. Those who cannot accept this principle should have the decency to keep silen…
Permalink to quote #107
Related quotes
Among so many conflicting ideas an so many different perspectives, the honest man is confused and distressed and the skeptic becomes wicked ... Since one must …
Napoleon BonaparteNapoleon Bonaparte quote #25 Geraldine: We must tell the truth! Prentice: That's a thoroughly defeatist attitude.
Joe OrtonJoe Orton quote #37 The first casualty when war comes is truth.
Hiram JohnsonHiram Johnson quote #1