Skip to content
quotesby

There are significant strategic interests [in Oceania], and there's a lot of stuff going on that's important. Not just the United States. For example, France is doing some really vicious things there, in fact they're just wiping out islands because they want them for nuclear tests. And when the socialist government in France is asked, 'Why to do this?', they say, 'Well look, we have to have nuclear tests.' Well, if you have to have nuclear tests, why not have them in southern France? [audience laughter] Why have them in some island in the Pacific? Well, the answer to that is clear, after all they're just a bunch of little brown people or something. But you can't say that exactly, especially if you're a socialist, so something else is said.

Noam Chomsky#139

PoliticsChomskyEthicsHuman rightsInternational relationsColonialismNuclearTesting

About this quote

What does it mean?
Chomsky argues that Western powers use nuclear testing in Pacific islands because indigenous populations are marginalized and their voices do not matter politically.
In plain terms
Nuclear tests happen on Pacific islands because the people living there are treated as less important.
What can you take from it?
Powerful nations often sacrifice marginalized regions for strategic interests.

Where it applies

  • policy debates
  • human rights advocacy
  • international law discussions

Putting it to work

  • advocate for indigenous rights
  • critique nuclear proliferation
  • analyze foreign policy

Questions to consider

  • How do we prioritize strategic interests over human rights?
  • What makes a population expendable?

Another view

The quote assumes all nuclear testing is inherently wrong without addressing potential security arguments.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. In certain intellectual circles in France, the very basis for discussion -- a minimal respect for facts and logic -- has been virtually abandoned.

    Permalink to quote #138
  2. The Grand Inquisitor explains that you have to create mysteries because otherwise the common people will be able to understand things. They have to be subordin…

    Permalink to quote #140
  3. Cuba has probably been the target of more international terrorism than the rest of the world combined and, therefore, in the American ideological system it is …

    Permalink to quote #137

Related quotes

  1. You cannot have humane Zionism, it is a contradiction in terms.

    Israel ShahakIsrael Shahak quote #1
  2. We would have to make clear to our German ally our disagreement on three points: treatment of the occupied countries, excesses towards the Jews, and relations …

    Ugo CavalleroUgo Cavallero quote #1
  3. 'In the social equation, the value of a single life is nil; in the cosmic equation, it is infinite... Not only communism, but any political movement which impl…

    Arthur KoestlerArthur Koestler quote #5