No less insidious is the cry for 'revolution,' at a time when not even the germs of new institutions exist, let alone the moral and political consciousness that could lead to a basic modification of social life. If there will be a 'revolution' in America today, it will no doubt be a move towards some variety of fascism. We must guard against the kind of revolutionary rhetoric that would have had Karl Marx burn down the British Museum because it was merely part of a repressive society. It would be criminal to overlook the serious flaws and inadequacies in our institutions, or to fail to utilize the substantial degree of freedom that most of us enjoy, within the framework of these flawed institutions, to modify them or even replace them by a better social order. One who pays some attention to history will not be surprised if those who cry most loudly that we must smash and destroy are later found among the administrators of some new system of repression.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Chomsky warns that revolutionary rhetoric without new institutions or moral consciousness can lead to fascism rather than social progress.
- In plain terms
- Demanding revolution without real plans can lead to worse systems like fascism.
- What can you take from it?
- Destructive change without constructive alternatives often fails or backfires.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What replaces old systems when they fall?
- Is destruction ever necessary for progress?
Another view
The view may underestimate the necessity of disruption to dismantle entrenched power.
More from Noam Chomsky
There's one aspect of the right-wing fury about cutting off Imus that I agree with. They argue, I suppose rightly, that Imus was pulled off because of pressure…
Permalink to quote #175 If you had asked my grandmother whether she is oppressed, she probably wouldn't have understood what you are talking about; that's life. If you'd asked my moth…
Permalink to quote #177 Demonstrations against such talks are legitimate. Shouting down is not, in my opinion.
Permalink to quote #174
Related quotes
Revolutionary movements attract those who are not good enough for established institutions as well as those who are too good for them.
George Bernard ShawGeorge Bernard Shaw quote #178 For a hundred years or more the world, our world, has been dying. And not one man, in these last hundred years or so, has been crazy enough to put a bomb up th…
Henry MillerHenry Miller quote #3 Go by reverently, and read with sober care How a great people, riding with defiant shouts The centaur of Revolution, Spurred and whipped to frenzy, Shook with …
Edgar Lee MastersEdgar Lee Masters quote #3