Take the Kyoto Protocol. Destruction of the environment is not only rational; it's exactly what you're taught to do in college. If you take an economics or a political science course, you're taught that humans are supposed to be rational wealth accumulators, each acting as an individual to maximize his own wealth in the market. The market is regarded as democratic because everybody has a vote. Of course, some have more votes than others because your votes depend on the number of dollars you have, but everybody participates and therefore it's called democratic. Well, suppose that we believe what we are taught. It follows that if there are dollars to be made, you destroy the environment. The reason is elementary. The people who are going to be harmed by this are your grandchildren, and they don't have any votes in the market. Their interests are worth zero. Anybody that pays attention to their grandchildren's interests is being irrational, because what you're supposed to do is maximize your own interests, measured by wealth, right now. Nothing else matters. So destroying the environment and militarizing outer space are rational policies, but within a framework of institutional lunacy. If you accept the institutional lunacy, then the policies are rational.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Economic education teaches rational wealth accumulation, which justifies environmental destruction since future generations have no market votes.
- In plain terms
- If you believe you must maximize wealth, you will harm the environment because victims like grandchildren cannot vote in the market.
- What can you take from it?
- Market logic often ignores harm to those without economic power.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do we value future generations in markets?
- Is profit always rational?
Another view
It assumes economic students automatically act on these teachings without ethical resistance.
More from Noam Chomsky
Remember, every business firm, like even a mom and pop grocery store, is a market imperfection. A firm is defined in economic theory as a market imperfection i…
Permalink to quote #29 See, capitalism is not fundamentally racist -- it can exploit racism for its purposes, but racism isn't built into it. Capitalism basically wants people to be …
Permalink to quote #31 I should say that when people talk about capitalism it's a bit of a joke. There's no such thing. No country, no business class, has ever been willing to subjec…
Permalink to quote #28
Related quotes
Thirty years from now the big university campuses will be relics. Universities won't survive. It's as large a change as when we first got the printed book. Do …
Peter F. DruckerPeter F. Drucker quote #7 For conservation to be successful it is necessary to take into consideration that it is a characteristic of man that he can only be relied upon to do anything …
Duke of Edinburgh PhilipDuke of Edinburgh Philip quote #1 The political situation starts to cool a little, but then we get the Ashcroft news and the market freaks out.
Jack BakerJack Baker quote #1