Skip to content
quotesby

Actually, on humanitarian intervention in general, I guess my view is not unlike the view that was attributed to Gandhi, accurately or not, when he was supposedly asked what he thought about western civilization. He is supposed to have said that he thought it would be a good idea. Similarly, humanitarian intervention would be a good idea, in principle. [...] can we expect that with the existing power structure, distribution of power in the world, there will be humanitarian intervention? There is nothing new about the question, of course. The idea of humanitarian intervention goes back to the days of the Concert of Europe a century ago - in the 19th Century there was lots of talk about civilizing missions and interventions that would do good things. The US intervened in the Philippines to 'uplift and christianize' the backward people, killing a couple of hundred thousand of them and destroying the place. The same thing happened in Haiti, the same thing happened with other countries. We cannot disregard the historical record and talk about an ideal world. It makes sense to work towards a better world, but it doesn't make any sense to have illusions about what the real world is.

Noam Chomsky#71

HistoryInterventionHumanitarianismHumanitarian

About this quote

What does it mean?
Humanitarian intervention is often presented as noble, but historically it has been used for imperialist aims, raising doubts about its current feasibility.
In plain terms
Humanitarian talks sounds good, but history shows it can be a cover for power.
What can you take from it?
Scrutinize humanitarian claims against past abuses.

Where it applies

  • policy formulation
  • ethical debate

Putting it to work

  • evaluate interventions critically
  • seek transparent objectives

Questions to consider

  • When can humanitarian action be legitimate?
  • How to prevent abuse?

Another view

Some interventions genuinely alleviate suffering; blanket dismissal may ignore positives.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. A good way of finding out who won a war, who lost a war, and what the war was about, is to ask who's cheering and who's depressed after it's over - this can gi…

    Permalink to quote #70
  2. Armies usually aren't interested in wars. They like preparation for war. But they have an understandable reluctance to fight a war. So I think if you look at, …

    Permalink to quote #72
  3. Naturally, any conqueror is going to play one group against another. For example, I think about 90% of the forces that the British used to control India were I…

    Permalink to quote #69

Related quotes

  1. 'Norman Borlaug is the living embodiment of the human quest for a hunger free world. His life is his message.'

    Norman BorlaugNorman Borlaug quote #9
  2. I have wanted to give Iraq a lesson in democracy - because we're experienced with it, you know. And, in democracy, after a hundred years, you have to let your …

    Kurt VonnegutKurt Vonnegut quote #12
  3. 'Dr. Norman Borlaug was the father of the Green Revolution that transformed much of the hungry Third World. As U.S. Food for Peace Administrator in the 1960s, …

    Norman BorlaugNorman Borlaug quote #12