Skip to content
quotesby

A good way of finding out who won a war, who lost a war, and what the war was about, is to ask who's cheering and who's depressed after it's over - this can give you interesting answers. So, for example, if you ask that question about the Second World War, you find out that the winners were the Nazis, the German industrialists who had supported Hitler, the Italian Fascists and the war criminals that were sent off to South America - they were all cheering at the end of the war. The losers of the war were the anti-fascist resistance, who were crushed all over the world. Either they were massacred like in Greece or South Korea, or just crushed like in Italy and France. That's the winners and losers. That tells you partly what the war was about. Now let's take the Cold War: Who's cheering and who's depressed? Let's take the East first. The people who are cheering are the former Communist Party bureaucracy who are now the capitalist entrepreneurs, rich beyond their wildest dreams, linked to Western capital, as in the traditional Third World model, and the new Mafia. They won the Cold War. The people of East Europe obviously lost the Cold War; they did succeed in overthrowing Soviet tyranny, which is a gain, but beyond that they've lost - they're in miserable shape and declining further. If you move to the West, who won and who lost? Well, the investors in General Motors certainly won. They now have this new Third World open again to exploitation - and they can use it against their own working classes. On the other hand, the workers in GM certainly didn't win, they lost. They lost the Cold War, because now there's another way to exploit them and oppress them and they're suffering from it.

Noam Chomsky#70

WarPowerHistoryVictory

About this quote

What does it mean?
You can tell who truly won a war by seeing who is happy afterwards, not by official records.
In plain terms
Who cheers after war tells you who really won.
What can you take from it?
Emotions after war reveal real winners.

Where it applies

  • analyzing wars
  • studying history

Putting it to work

  • look beyond official victory
  • track emotional reactions

Questions to consider

  • Who wins wars?
  • What does victory mean?

Another view

It ignores those who suffer regardless of winners.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. Naturally, any conqueror is going to play one group against another. For example, I think about 90% of the forces that the British used to control India were I…

    Permalink to quote #69
  2. Actually, on humanitarian intervention in general, I guess my view is not unlike the view that was attributed to Gandhi, accurately or not, when he was suppose…

    Permalink to quote #71
  3. Non-violent resistance activities cannot succeed against an enemy that is able freely to use violence. That's pretty obvious. You can't have non-violent resist…

    Permalink to quote #68

Related quotes

  1. The greatest pleasure is to vanquish your enemies and chase them before you, to rob them of their wealth and see those dear to them bathed in tears, to ride th…

    Genghis KhanGenghis Khan quote #11
  2. Soldiers! The great battle in the Vistula sector is finished. The Polish Army is annihilated. The operations against Poland are thus concluded.

    Walther von BrauchitschWalther von Brauchitsch quote #1
  3. I am thankful for the kind treatment during my captivity and I ask God to accept me with mercy.

    Hans FrankHans Frank quote #1