Let me just put the whole thing in a kind of mundane level. Like, suppose you walk out in the street, this evening, and you see a crime being committed, you know, somebody is robbing someone else. Well, you have three choices. One choice is to try to stop it, maybe you call 911 or something. Another choice is to do nothing. A third choice is to pick up an assault rifle and kill 'em both, and kill a bystander at the same time. Well, suppose you do that, and somebody says, 'Well, you know, why did you do that?' And you say, 'Look, I couldn't stand by and do nothing.' I mean, is that a response? If you can think of nothing that wouldn't do harm, then do nothing. And the same is true, magnified, in international affairs. Apart from the fact that there were things that could have been done.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Chomsky uses a street analogy to argue that doing nothing is often better than taking harmful action in international affairs.
- In plain terms
- If you have no good plan to fix a problem, doing nothing is better than causing more harm.
- What can you take from it?
- Inaction is sometimes preferable to intervention that causes more damage.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When is intervention justified?
- How do we weigh inaction against action?
Another view
The analogy oversimplifies complex geopolitical realities.
More from Noam Chomsky
Regarding Operation Provide Relief/Operation Restore Hope/Battle of Mogadishu: [Q: what did the United States have to gain by intervening in Somalia?] In Somal…
Permalink to quote #88 The United States is not going in there to save the oppressed. If we wanted to save the oppressed we could have supported the nonviolent movement instead of se…
Permalink to quote #90 The crisis began with the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait a year ago. There was some fighting, leaving hundreds killed according to Human Rights groups. That hardly q…
Permalink to quote #87
Related quotes
If we launch a pre-emptive strike on Iraq we lose all moral authority,
Jesse JacksonJesse Jackson quote #6 It is very difficult to do one's duty. I was considered a barbarian because at the storming of the Praga 7,000 people were killed. Europe says that I am a mons…
Alexander SuvorovAlexander Suvorov quote #8 This is a time for action - not for war, but for mobilization of every bit of peace machinery. It is also a time for facing the fact that you cannot use a weap…
Eleanor RooseveltEleanor Roosevelt quote #44