At the present day, civilized opinion is a curious mental mixture. The military instincts and ideals are as strong as ever, but they are confronted by reflective criticisms which sorely curb their ancient freedom. Innumerable writers are showing up the bestial side of military service. Pure loot and mastery seem no longer morally allowable motives, and pretexts must be found for attributing them solely to the enemy.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Civilized opinion mixes strong military instincts with reflective criticism that limits their freedom, exposing the harsh side of military service.
- In plain terms
- People still have strong war instincts, but they are now heavily criticized.
- What can you take from it?
- Recognize that moral scrutiny can temper aggressive impulses.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do we balance security with moral critique?
- When does criticism become counterproductive?
Another view
The quote assumes a universal civilizing influence that may not exist everywhere.
More from William James
We inherit the warlike type; and for most of the capacities of heroism that the human race is full of we have to thank this cruel history. Dead men tell no tal…
Permalink to quote #92 It would seem that common sense and reason ought to find a way to reach agreement in every conflict of honest interests. I myself think it our bounden duty to …
Permalink to quote #94 Alexander's career was piracy pure and simple, nothing but an orgy of power and plunder, made romantic by the character of the hero. There was no rational purp…
Permalink to quote #91
Related quotes
I either want less corruption, or more chance to participate in it.
Ashleigh BrilliantAshleigh Brilliant quote #4 War is a crime which involves all other crimes.
Henry BroughamHenry Brougham quote #10 The pinning on of stars reaches its full cynical significance when sanctified valour and bereaved families are used to lend dignity to wars stupidly fought. Th…
John Ralston SaulJohn Ralston Saul quote #11