It is true that numerous instances are not always necessary to establish a law, provided the essential and relevant circumstances can easily be disentangled. But, in history, so many circumstances of a small and accidental nature are relevant, that no broad and simple uniformities are possible. Where our main endeavour is to discover general laws, we regard these as intrinsically more valuable than any of the facts which they inter-connect. In astronomy, the law of gravitation is plainly better worth knowing than the position of a particular planet on a particular night, or even on every night throughout a year. There are in the law a splendour and simplicity and sense of mastery which illuminate a mass of otherwise uninteresting details... But in history the matter is far otherwise... Historical facts, many of them, have an intrinsic value, a profound interest on their own account, which makes them worthy of study, quite apart from any possibility of linking them together by means of causal laws.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Russell contrasts law‑seeking in science, where simple universal laws are valuable, with history, where individual facts have intrinsic worth.
- In plain terms
- Science values simple laws; history values unique facts.
- What can you take from it?
- Different fields prioritize different kinds of knowledge.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When should we favor general laws over specific facts?
- Do historical details ever form broader principles?
Another view
The claim that simple laws are always superior may overlook complexity.
More from Bertrand Russell
Pure mathematics consists entirely of assertions to the effect that, if such and such a proposition is true of anything, then such and such another proposition…
Permalink to quote #5 The number of syllables in the English names of finite integers tends to increase as the integers grow larger, and must gradually increase indefinitely, since …
Permalink to quote #7 Thee might observe incidentally that if the state paid for child-bearing it might and ought to require a medical certificate that the parents were such as to g…
Permalink to quote #4
Related quotes
All in all, Engels talked so much rot of every kind, that now all the world's academies of science should be directed to rectify his mistakes and idiocies.
Aleksandr ZinovyevAleksandr Zinovyev quote #4 Il ne faut pas comparer la marche de la science aux transformations d'une ville, ou les edifices vieillis sont impitoyablement jetes a bas pour faire place aux…
Henri PoincareHenri Poincare quote #9 In the eighteenth century it was often convenient to regard man as a clockwork automaton. In the nineteenth century, with Newtonian physics pretty well assimil…
Thomas PynchonThomas Pynchon quote #11