If the country had been flooded with several 100,000 troops, as Shinseki advised, and if the orders had not been so grotesque (stand by quietly while the cultural wealth of Iraq, and humanity, was destroyed in a way reminiscent of the Mongol invasion; treat the population with contempt and brutality; allow the society to reconstruct instead of imposing ultra-liberal measures bound to destroy it, etc.), then the place might have been pacified as well as northern Europe was under the Nazis -- or the Philippines, after a decade of extreme brutality, victory having been declared repeatedly during those years. Just how one judges such an outcome depends on other choices.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author argues that different military strategies could have led to different outcomes in Iraq, comparing the situation to historical occupations.
- In plain terms
- Different choices in troop deployment and rules of engagement might have changed the result of the Iraq war.
- What can you take from it?
- Military strategy and rules of engagement significantly impact occupation outcomes.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do rules of engagement affect civilian treatment?
- What defines a successful occupation?
Another view
The comparison to Nazi Europe and the Philippines is controversial and may oversimplify complex historical contexts.
More from Noam Chomsky
It should have been the easiest invasion in history, and the incompetence and arrogance of the Pentagon planners turned it into a total catastrophe. So yes, it…
Permalink to quote #120 An extensive and detailed poll was released by ABC, BBC, and Japan's NHK, on September 10. The media had to labor overtime to keep it out of sight, because it …
Permalink to quote #122 The US-UK would, doubtless, be as eager to draw their troops down in Iraq as Hitler was in occupied France and Norway, and the Russians were in Eastern Europe.…
Permalink to quote #119
Related quotes
We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity. We weren't punctilious about locating and punishing only Hitler and his …
Ann CoulterAnn Coulter quote #13 The combination of modern ordnance and outdated tactics had, as ever, created enormous casualties on both sides.
Iain BanksIain Banks quote #1 'There has been a good deal of comment-some of it quite outlandish-about what our postwar requirements might be in Iraq. Some of the higher end predictions we …
Paul WolfowitzPaul Wolfowitz quote #1